why do russian soldiers tilt their heads

By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. They were first introduced in the mid-19th century. The old tradition of giving military salute only when the head is covered is still preserved. Can someone confirm this, and if so, tell me what the Russian word or words for it is? In both of the instruments shown in the question, there is no doubt that brown is showing above the left wingtip of the airplane icon, meaning that the airplane is banked left. It is a criminal offence in Russia to report anything other than the official figures. I could understand the "looking to the side towards your superior" while marching, but why do they all tilt their head up way to high (as if they were observing something 40m in the air instead of the military dude standing right there). It demonstrates how a left turn on the Soviet display is similar to a right turn in a Western display. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. The mental picture of motion is different for different people. WebThe Kremlin Regiment, a group of special guards tasked with protecting high-profile Russian leaders, seem a bit odd.When leaders like Putin walk past, they tilt their heads at jaunty Are there (ideas for) GNSS based attitude indicators? In 1973 the unit was renamed the Separate Red Banner Kremlin Regiment, later receiving an Order of the October Revolution. Is there a word or phrase in Russian for this particular salute-like gesture? What means of navigation did commercial Soviet airplanes use in the 50s-90s? READ MORE: 3 Russian military men who only knew how to win. You dont need Russian citizenship to join the military and, like the French Foreign Legion, serving in the military guarantees a foreign candidate citizenship. Folder's list view has different sized fonts in different folders. How to force Unity Editor/TestRunner to run at full speed when in background? In the accident flight, he saw that the most predominant line - the horizon on the Western display - was angled to the left. As an example, if pilot must perform sudden and unexpected upset recovery, to correct the attitude, he might be misled by a very predominant diagonal horizon line on the Western display. What else is special about the Russian military salute and what is its history? What differentiates living as mere roommates from living in a marriage-like relationship? Searching for possible explanations, we encountered a training manual of the former Russian KGB, they wrote. Russian Defense Ministry Press Service/Associated Press, NOW WATCH: VIDEO: Why Russia's military is failing so far in Ukraine. When leaders like Putin walk past, they tilt their heads at jaunty angles and watch them walking. The Russian soldier compared the shelling to the series of bombings in Russian apartments in 1999. According to it, the headwear (in those times, a tricorn), was to be taken off with the soldiers left hand, 6 steps before approaching a person of a senior rank, and held in the left hand until the senior is 6 steps away. However, when, for example, President Vladimir Putin, dressed in civilian clothing, is saluted, he doesnt return the salute, because he is not in uniform and isnt wearing military headwear (unlike the U.S. President, for example). 10,000 hours later and I still sometimes get tripped up. Archived post. The Moscow Times highlights 10 of the most common superstitions travelers to @Claudix, the image used in your original question can be misleading for 2 reasons: Both instruments are tilted to the right side on your original image. WebRussia is facing growing accusations that its military committed war crimes in Ukraine after more details and witness accounts emerged over the weekend about civilian executions in This confusion is also suggested to play a part in. This is ("military salute"). In Russia, the salute was to be performed solely when the head was covered with military headwear. He claimed a charter reads: "To carry out the military greeting on the spot outside the building for three or four steps before the chief turn in his direction, take the drill stand and look into his face, turning his head after him.". To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. The pilots were manually flying in a busy phase of flight. Do the soldiers have a clear sense of the wars purpose? This can be confusing to a pilot who assumes that the symbolic airplane (which never moves) is meant to illustrate the airplane, while the LED lights are meant to depict the horizon, after the manner of a Western-style attitude indicator rather than a turn coordinator. In a picture: in working hours of the International naval salon. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. There is no question that Ukrainians have the will to fight and have already put up a heroic resistance. How are attitude indicators kept accurate? ", Western planes should have had a sphere/trackball to turn the "rest of the world" instead of a yoke/sidestick to turn the plane. He walks up this long stairway lined with soldiers holding their rifles at the salute, and as he To convince them to continue, the scientist would often have to assure them that the pain they were inflicting served a greater good in this case, Science. According to the Center for Strategic and WebIn contrast, on the Russian instrument, the aircraft silhouette is moving in front of a static horizon. How is the drift corrected in INS-driven attitude/heading indicators? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. There are a couple of reasons for ceremonial hats being so big (and no, its not because Russians have oversized heads). Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. Aviation Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for aircraft pilots, mechanics, and enthusiasts. Shoulder boards are entirely ceremonial for both uniforms, both in entirely different designs, despite the ranks of the troops being the same between each. It's so easy to sit in our comfy lounge chairs and wonder how on Earth pilots get things wrong. This is from a video of Mr. Putin making some kind of ceremonial entrance into the Kremlin. Have your say in our news democracy. If this were true, then the Russian army would be greeted as liberators as their tanks rolled through Ukrainian towns and villages. The Jewish victims of Brownings ordinary men had been systematically dehumanized by Nazi policy and ideology and cast as an existential threat to the survival of the German nation. One can not instill diligence, when one himself does not comply with it.. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. You can find all information on the Defense Ministrys website for prospective candidates, as well as where youll find a recruitment office. Thank you! The aforementioned rules were largely employed in the Red Army of the USSR. A study published in the British Medical Journal on Tuesday notes the Russian Just something I noticed during late night YouTube watching around the whole conflict in Ukraine. What Russians meant to do with Lenins mausoleum, The Order of Victory, the worlds most expensive military decoration (VIDEO), Why Russian paratroopers are among the best in the world (PHOTOS), Russian sailors' second skin: The tel'nyashka. Maggie Fox is a senior writer for NBC News and TODAY, covering health policy, science, medical treatments and disease. It has also recently acquired special ceremonial uniforms closely modeled on those worn on parade by the infantry and the cavalry of the Russian Imperial Guard until 1914. In response, Russian soldiers fired their guns into the air. They found killing Jewish civilians who spoke German, like them, especially difficult. The soldiers ride into the city that day had been a touch-and-go affair; the Russians had tried to hit the armored vehicle twice when it was going through the mud, the driver said. Ukrainian intelligence said in a Facebook post that the call between the soldier and wife makes it "obvious that the Kremlin is indifferent not only to its military, but also to civilian Russians, who also suffered from the shelling of Russian troops.". But what about Russian soldiers? But why is it raised to the head? He claimed a charter reads: "To carry out the military greeting on the spot outside the building for three or four steps before the chief turn in his direction, take the drill stand and look into his face, turning his head after him.". That said, in a really stressful situation all the complicated mental pictures disintegrate, and the most basic instincts remain Just adding few more points to the already existing answers. I had always wondered what that meant, but these soldiers are making this very distinctive expressive salute-like movement, and I suspect that this is what he meant. But as Russian soldiers find themselves face to face with Ukrainian civilians more and more, it does raise the question of how far they are willing to obey orders. WebThe Kremlin Regiment, a group of special guards tasked with protecting high-profile Russian leaders, seem a bit odd. This image is taken from this short video (yellow arrows were added). xcolor: How to get the complementary color. The UKMK and the 1st Division were separate public security units with neither subordinate to the other, which would not prevent them collaborating closely in Kremlin security activities. There are several explanations for this. Some pilots have felt that a simple arc of LED lights across the top of display representing the movement of the needle of a traditional turn rate indicator, with the airplane symbol completely omitted, would have been a more effective presentation of the information sensed by this instrument. In historical dress, gorgets are reflective of imperial officer insignia, whereas in modern dress, these are reflective of the Soviet general insignia. What are the common responses to " ?". In Remain a human being. By the end of the day, the city still under Russian attack was filled with more billboards with appeals and approbations: Do not ruin your life for Putin. They were first introduced in the mid-19th century, You can find all information on the Defense Ministrys. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. They thought they were being sent to do training exercises. For historical dress, troops wear shakos with a sunburst Imperial eagle emblem. Brownings argument relied on the famous Milgram experiments, conducted by the psychologist Stanley Milgram in the early 1960s. Killing is hard even in the military, under orders. Thanks for contributing an answer to Russian Language Stack Exchange! WebThe Red Guards (Russian: Krasnaya Gvardiya) were armed groups of workers formed during the Russian Revolution of 1917, although the designation and concept dates back to Moscow during the Revolution of 1905.In 1917 the volunteers of the Red Guard and their elected leaders formed the main strike force of the Bolsheviks.These workers' militias were created Secondly, the headgear is large because the designer who Adding to @Ben's answer, another source of confusion when it comes to human factors is even present within Western attitude indicators. Thank you, I finally understood the reason behind the confusion. Go back to your family!; Do not become a murderer. It's not them. WebThe National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine characterized the blame as "an attempt to ignite anti-Ukraine hysteria in Russia," according to Radio Free Europe, a US-funded Click here to find out more. The whole world is with Ukraine! , (. This visual echo would have confirmed, for the Russian public back home, Russias official explanation for the invasion: the denazification of Ukraine. This can add to the confusion when compared with the Russian style. On September 2, 2002 on the basis of the 11th Cavalry Regiment (the Moscow Military District movie-making cavalry unit) a cavalry escort unit was formed as part of the Presidential Regiment. Others view (or can easily imagine) themselves from the third person view, and they are more at home with the reverse (and 'north up') display. St. Petersburg. Perhaps Russia expected for the world to stand by as it seized control of Ukrainian territory, just as it held back in 2014 when Russia annexed Crimea. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. This product (unlike some later products by the same company which really are turn coordinators with a sensing axis canted away from the vertical to pick up roll as well as yaw) is really just a yaw rate indicator and nothing more. "I repeatedly observed the training of the presidential regiment and was simply delighted with the clarity and correctness of the movements. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Thanks for sharing this experience, but how come that these (Western) aircraft had 'Russian' FAI? This fantasy holds at least part of the Russian public captive especially those whose primary source of information is state media rather than social media. These are worn in addition to modern style dress uniforms adapted from those utilised during the Soviet period. The upper instrument is the Western display, the bottom one is the "Russian". Just something I noticed during late night YouTube watching around the whole conflict in Identify blue/translucent jelly-like animal on beach, "Signpost" puzzle from Tatham's collection. Milgrams volunteers were given the role of teacher and told that the experiment was a study of whether pain improved memory. Russia has accused Ukrainian forces of executing a group of Russian prisoners, an action it has described as a war crime. Here's an example https://focus.ua/files/images/0/-87397.jpg Soldiers here were given a command to align to tribune and salute the president. Another, more plausible, is that this is a rudimental gesture, performed instead of lifting ones headwear to show respect. When the commander passes him by a step, then his hand can be lowered.. Currently, two persons must be saluted by military men, even when these persons are not wearing military uniform the President of the Russian Federation and the Prime Minister. Brownings book offered an explanation, or at least one explanation, for how ordinary people can take part in extraordinary evil. by the whole regiment in the presence of a general at a parade), such rule was installed: A full hand military salute is performed by the head of the military unit, while all members of the unit standing at attention, their eyes looking in the direction of the high-ranked commander. Killing Brownings story showed is hard. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. The regiment ensures the security of the Kremlin, its treasures, and state officials. The Kremlin Regiment, a group of special guards tasked with protecting high-profile Russian leaders, seem a bit odd. Passing negative parameters to a wolframscript, What are the arguments for/against anonymous authorship of the Gospels. Victoria Smolkin is associate professor ofhistory atWesleyanUniversity and the author of ASacredSpaceIs Never Empty: AHistoryof Soviet Atheism. To avoid this problem, at least one pilot has found it helpful to completely hide the aircraft symbol behind a picture of a fixed horizon line, with brown earth below and blue sky above, or better yet, to completely hide the airplane symbol behind an abstract symbol designed to suggest that the left and right wingtips of the airplane are moving in an arc with their present position indicated by the LED lights. Neurology professor Bastiaan Bloem of the Radboud University Medical Center in the Netherlands and colleagues had noticed that Putin often walks with his right arm held rigid, while his left arms swings freely. This is, however, not how pilots would see the Attitude Indicator (the instrument itself). Unexpected uint64 behaviour 0xFFFF'FFFF'FFFF'FFFF - 1 = 0? Now "foreign servicemen can participate in operations during martial law, as well as in armed conflicts, in accordance with [the] generally accepted principles of international law, international agreements, and Russian legislation," said a new order published on the Kremlin website. This should also shed some light on the reverse question. On January 28, 1936, the battalion and the Kremlin Garrison (Komendatura Kremlya), to which it was subordinated were transferred from the People's Commissariat of Defense of the USSR to the People's Commissariat of Internal Affairs (NKVD) of the USSR. Boeing and Airbus aircraft use the style on the left, whereas Garmin (and mechanical gyros in light aircraft) the style on the right. Click here to find out more. All this is achieved by constant training and a special method of commanders, which has already been transmitted by many generations of ceremonial troops first to the USSR, and now to Russia," he explained on a blog. If the null hypothesis is never really true, is there a point to using a statistical test without a priori power analysis? https://focus.ua/files/images/0/-87397.jpg, New blog post from our CEO Prashanth: Community is the future of AI, Improving the copy in the close modal and post notices - 2023 edition. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. ), there came a need for a universal military salute. Indeed, it is precisely this cultural proximity that seems to be having a powerful effect on Russian military morale. Leave without blood on your hands; Instead of flowers, bullets await you. A boy can regenerate, so demons eat him for years. In a left turn, the lower left and upper right LED lights would be illuminated. They proclaim that the Kiev regime the democratically elected Ukrainian government is made up of drug addicts and Neo-Nazis. They warn that Ukrainian soldiers use children, women, and the elderly as human shields. They talk about refugees from the Donbas and their harrowing tales of life in a fascist Ukraine, and warn of a genocide of Russian speakers. Is "I didn't think it was serious" usually a good defence against "duty to rescue"? Like "" instead of ""? Vladimir Andreeff, a man who says he is a Russian army veteran, says this is all part of the standard "military greeting". Milgram wanted to understand obedience to authority: Under what conditions would people follow orders, even when those orders ran counter to their moral sense? Yesterday I watched a documentary on Crossair Flight 498 accident. Get the week's best stories straight to your inbox. Why do dogs tilt their heads? I don't think that's such a big deal because it's the blue/brown picture that dominates your vision and you are generally following the flight director commands, so differences in the bank angle and slip/skid brick presentation are secondary. There is just a tendency for many people to dissect pilot actions in an accident and throw accusations without realising that in the right circumstances, everyone can make a fatal mistake. Leave! They also tend to use maps with 'track up' orientation. Since 1997 the Kremlin Regiment has resumed guard duties by presidential decree on the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier and its Eternal Flame, keeping alive the legacy of those who served on the Eastern Front. To better illustrate your question, I'm attaching this image to show 2 different ways For those who initially refused, the argument that ultimately convinced them to take part in mass murder was that their non-participation would place a heavier burden on their comrades. I wonder who came up with the idea to show the bank indicator arrow at the opposite side of the bank. This is not to say that the Russian army has not already inflicted devastating damage in Ukraine, or that it will not inflict more. He walks up this long stairway lined with soldiers holding their rifles at the salute, and as he walks through, each soldier holds his head back with their faces cocked towards him, tracking him. Enjoy watching this other masterpiece by Russian troops, In the West, its called the Briton shirt, but in, . What are the advantages of running a power tool on 240 V vs 120 V? WebWhy do Russian soldiers hold their head at a weird angle while saluting or while at attention. So, while it may seem easy-peasy to adapt to, until the western format has been internalized as deeply as the Russian one, there can be a tendency to start to mentally revert, causing more mental conflict and accelerating the mental tunnel vision effect, ending up in mental freeze mode. Perhaps it even expected to stage its own iconic Reichstag moment, raising the Russian flag over a defeated Kyiv just as Soviet soldiers had done over a defeated Berlin in the last days of the war against Nazi Germany. But by this point he was already disoriented and confused, with the first officer's instructions ambiguous and worsening his dilemma. They ask them why theyve come. I'd rather +1 with this - technically it counts as, @Quassnoi as far as I know (but I'm not a military person and can be wrong) it's still, - - - . Earlier this week a friend in Kyiv posted a photo she took of a billboard message addressed directly to Russian soldiers and imploring them to stop: How will you be able to look your children in the eyes? it asked. What does 'They're at four. Click the upvote icon at the top of the page to help raise this article through the indy100 rankings. In modern dress, all soldiers wear golden aigulettes and golden belts. I was taught in and flew single and twin Pipers, Beechcraft and Cesnas in the 1980's. This corresponds to the direct ('Western') indication, and such people must adapt to it more naturally. WebWe would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us. Although I understand the logic in the Western instrument is better, personally I prefer the Russian style. The error didn't happen without context. But there are fields where Russian military and industrial complex need to work on. But it appears to be different on the Russian side. Scan this QR code to download the app now. Even without the artificial horizon mixup, the conditions were ripe for spatial disorientation. It seemed that almost two thirds of the subjects were willing to obey orders and inflict pain on an innocent human being; that ordinary Americans in the 1960s were not unlike Brownings ordinary men.. They appeal to the Russian soldier not as a military combatant or moral monster but as an ordinary person with a family and children, a human being with a conscience, someone like themselves. WebNow researchers think they know why: Its most likely KGB weapons training at work. How will you be able to look your children in the eyes. 1 Dogs tilt their heads when they're paying attention to you Credit: Getty It means that while the quizzical head cock might give off an air of confusion, it's actually a sign of raised attention. It has managed so far to withstand the Russian assault, which included attacks on multiple fronts aimed at Ukraines major cities, including its capital, Kyiv. Weighted sum of two random variables ranked by first order stochastic dominance, Short story about swapping bodies as a job; the person who hires the main character misuses his body. Theyve also seen a broad swath of Ukrainian civilians who in perfect Russian, using profanity questioned why Russian soldiers were invading their country, and told them, often impolitely, to go home. Tsar Nicholas II Visiting The Russian Front, May 1915. "Apartments were blown up in Moscow, like they were terrorists.". Instead, Slowly through the 19th century, the so-called Polish salute (or Two-fingered salute) came to be used in the Russian Imperial army. They get in their way, as they did in Melitopol, chanting fascists! and occupants! as a Russian convoy tried to advance. Two MacBook Pro with same model number (A1286) but different year, Adding EV Charger (100A) in secondary panel (100A) fed off main (200A). The lower ranks salute the higher ranks first. The commander of the Black Sea Fleet, Vice Admiral Igor Osipov, salutes the head of the Black Sea Higher Naval School After P. S. Nakhimov, Rear Admiral Alexander Grinkevich, What about returning the military salute? The Kremlin Regiment (Russian: , romanized:Kremlyovskiy polk), also called the Presidential Regiment (Russian: , romanized:Prezidentskiy polk), is a unique military regiment and part of the Russian Federal Protective Service with the status of a special unit. Officers of the 13th Yerevan Grenadier Regiment of the Russian Imperial Army, After the mid-19th century, the Two-fingered salute was replaced with a full-hand salute. This possibility for confusion is one reason among several why many pilots prefer the traditional "turn rate indicator" (aka "turn and slip indicator") to the "turn coordinator"-- despite the fact that by sensing roll as well as yaw, the "turn coordinator" tends to give a stronger indication than the turn rate indicator when an aircraft first starts to roll into an unwanted turn. Recruits seen at the outfit room before leaving for the army service from a Kazan conscription office. My best guess is, that all these mannerisms have some history grounded in some practical habit, but this just confuses me. Note the roll angle and its indicator in a right turn above for both styles. Conversely, the direct ('Western') indication is more the result of gradual evolution: early AH had a gyro right in the central ball (or directly connected to it) that represents the horizon, and it naturally kept the 'true' horizon line.

Is Red Skelton's Daughter Still Alive, Articles W